This shortcut caramel sauce takes about 15 minutes to make. Use it over ice cream, as a dip, or, if you really love caramel, spread it thinly on toast and then sprinkle on a little ground cinnamon for the ultimate cinnamon toast.
How to Make Caramel Sauce: Selecting the Caramel
How much do I love caramel sauce? Let me count the ways. First, I love it on ice cream. Then I love a little– just a hint–drizzled over a cup of iced coffee. And then there’s…eating it off a spoon.
The problem? I don’t like most commercial caramel sauce. Too often, they have an off-flavor. That means I have to make my own caramel sauce. sigh
To make a traditional caramel sauce, you cook sugar until it melts and reaches the caramel stage. This isn’t hard but it takes some time.
Thankfully, theres’s a shortcut. Enter: pre-made caramel.
Select a firm caramel that you like eating. I love Merckens caramel with Peter’s caramel coming in a close second. Unless you have a local candy making supply store, you’ll need to order these online. I think it’s worth it.
Since Kraft is the most easily found brand of caramel, I used it for this batch. It came out really nice. But, I have to admit, I still prefer the taste of Merckens caramel.
How to Make Caramel Sauce: Cooking the Sauce
Place unwrapped caramel candies into a heavy-bottomed pot. If you used a block caramel, cut it into pieces before putting it into the pot.
At first, the water will bubble madly and the caramels stick together in a large blob. This is normal. Stir the mixture, blob and all, to prevent, you guessed it, burning.
After a few minutes, all of the caramels melt. Almost. You can see how a few lumps in the sauce. Don’t add the cream yet or the lumps won’t cook out. You want the caramel sauce to be nice and smooth before you add the next ingredient.
This is what we want. It’s a smooth caramel with gentle bubbles and no lumps. Now it’s time to add the half-and-half.
When you add half and half to the pot, the caramel sauce bubbles up vigorously. Within a few seconds, the bubbles calm down. Select a pot with high sides to prevent the whole thing from spilling over.
Done.
As soon as the half and half is fully incorporated into the sauce, remove the pan from the heat. If you prefer a vanilla caramel sauce, add some vanilla extract. This makes for a 3-Ingredient caramel sauce but who’s counting? Pour the sauce into a heatproof container. I like to use two 8-ounce Ball jelly jars.
Pour the sauce into a heatproof glass container. I like to use two 8-ounce Ball jelly jars.
Then all that’s left to do is use it (on everything!)
2 Ingredient Caramel Sauce
Firm caramels and half and half are the only ingredients needed to make this recipe. (I don't count water as an ingredient.) If you prefer a vanilla caramel, add a teaspoon to the batch. It makes for a lovely 3-Ingredient Caramel Sauce.
Ingredients
- 11 ounces firm caramels, unwrapped and cut into pieces if needed.
- 2 tablespoons water
- 1/2 cup half-and-half
- 1 teaspoon vanilla extract optional
Instructions
-
Place caramels and water into a 2 quart heavy-bottomed sauce pot. Heat over medium-low heat until the caramels melt. Stir constantly to prevent the caramels from burning.
-
Once all the caramels have melted and the mixture is smooth, add the half and half. The sauce will bubble up and then settle down. Stir to combine.
-
Remove the pan from the heat and stir in the vanilla extract if desired. Pour sauce into two heatproof jars.
-
Store caramel sauce in the refrigerator for up to four weeks.
Recipe Notes
Caramel Sauce (Merckens or Peter's Caramel)
Follow this recipe when using Merckens or Peter's block caramel.
Ingredients
- 16 ounces Merckens or Peter's firm caramel
- 2 tablespoons water
- 3/4 cup half and half
Instructions
-
Cut the caramel into large pieces. Combine caramel and water in a heavy-bottomed pot. Heat over medium-low heat until the caramel melts. Stir constantly to prevent burning.
-
Once all the caramels have melted and the mixture is smooth, add the half and half. The sauce will bubble up and then settle down. Stir to combine.
-
Remove the pan from the heat and pour sauce into two heatproof jars.
-
Store caramel sauce in the refrigerator for up to four weeks.
Note: This page contains Amazon affiliate links to products I love and use. If you purchase the product using the link, I earn a small commission which helps to support the site.
Mary Ann says
Qaida love Caramel Sauce and will certainly give this a try!
Agness of Run Agness Run says
What a mouthwatering recipe, Elizabeth! I will prepare it as soon as possible.
Kit says
Thanks for the recipe, Elizabeth!
Ness says
Can you use heavy cream instead of half and half?
The recipe looks amazing.
Elizabeth says
That should work. The mac and cheese will be richer. 🙂
Luvstoshop says
Not only is this recipe super easy, your opening remarks made me smile. I’d rather eat a beautiful sea salt caramel than a whole box of chocolates!
Chesley says
Me too!! I want something chocolate-y occasionally, but I can do caramel every day!
Jim Holland says
Can I use old caramels and heavy cream to make caramel sauce?
Elizabeth says
That should work as long as you have enough! Enjoy!
Maggie says
Made a few adjustments and it turned out great! Another suggestion is to use carnation evaporated milk. It is shelf stable and helps the sauce not to split. The bonus is that it’s only 2% instead of 18, and using Peter’s caramel blocks makes the sauce every bit as rich and luscious! I add rum and extra vanilla so whats not to love! Thanks for sharing. Happy holidays!
Chanelle says
What were the adjustments you made with the evaporated milk?